Judge tosses New York City's climate change lawsuit against major oil companies

US judge dismisses NY climate lawsuit against oil titans

Even though the NY and California lawsuits have been dropped, several cities are still continuing to try to fight climate change through nuisance suits.

In the last month, the cities of NY and Oakland, both represented by the able lawyers at Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro, failed to persuade federal judges to allow them to proceed with nuisance claims blaming major oil companies for selling fossil fuel in the face of overwhelming evidence that oil and gas emissions are responsible for climate change.

U.S. District Judge John Keenan tossed out the suit against Exxon Mobil, Chevron, BP, Royal Dutch Shell and ConocoPhillips, ruling that Congress and the executive branch, not courts, must tackle the issue of climate change, Bloomberg reported.

But on Thursday, John F. Keenan, U.S. District Court judge for the Southern District of NY, granted the defendants' request to dismiss the complaint. To litigate such an action for injuries from foreign greenhouse gas emissions in federal court would severely infringe upon the foreign-policy decisions that are squarely within the purview of the political branches of the US government.

A spokesman for New York Mayor Bill de Blasio told Courthouse News Service that the city intends to appeal.

More news: Israeli ‘LGBT Strike’ Begins As Protesters Block Highway To Blast Surrogacy Law

"Judge Keenan's decision reaffirms our view that climate change is a complex societal challenge that requires sound governmental policy and is not an issue for the courts", Shell said in a statement. "Accordingly, the court will exercise appropriate caution and decline to recognize such a cause of action". "But there is at least one other court that found the exact opposite, namely that state public nuisance claims are available".

However, environmental law experts said judges trying similar cases in state courts might rule differently. Judge Keenan said the framing didn't make a difference. "The court relied on bedrock Supreme Court precedent to reject these baseless claims". "It's time that fossil fuel companies pay their fair share". In January, the city first filed a lawsuit against the energy companies, arguing that they were liable for damages the city incurred as a result of global warming. "The benefits of fossil fuels are worldwide", Judge Alsup said in his ruling.

Although Keenan acknowledged in his Thursday ruling (pdf) that "climate science clearly demonstrates that the burning of fossil fuels is the primary cause of climate change", the judge ultimately concluded that the suit was not allowed under federal common law and the Clean Air Act, and that "the city's claims interfere with separation of powers and foreign policy".

Keenan said the lawsuit implicates countless foreign governments and their laws and policies.

Despite the legally unchallenged culpability of the oil companies, the judge said that New York City's grievances couldn't be addressed in the way the city wanted.

Related News:

Most liked

British Open 2018 Tiger Woods updates
But, Molinari wasn't the only story of the day. "Next thing, lo and behold, I'm tied for the lead, and then I'm leading it". His world golf ranking has risen to No. 50, meaning he's qualified for the WGC-Bridgestone Invitational next month.

Miss Lang’ata Prison Ruth Kamande who stabbed lover handed death sentence
The judge said although the Supreme Court held that death sentence is not mandatory, Kamande did not deserve mercy. Last year, she sat the Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education examination at the prison and scored an A-.

Mavericks, Yogi Ferrell Agree to Deal
He will be a backup shooting guard next season after averaging 10.2 points, three assists and 2.5 rebounds per game. Nevertheless, he remains an integral piece in a rebuilding squad that posted a dismal 24-58 record last season.

Neymar insists he will stay at PSG to win titles
I have been aware of this responsibility, not only for Brazil, but also in club football, since I was 17 or 18 years old. It's complicated but if you haven't experienced that you will never understand.

Proteas Warned to Expect More Spin-Friendly Conditions
South Africa made a terrible start to their month-long tour to the Island nation as they lost the opening Test in Galle inside three days.

One giant sale: Neil Armstrong’s collection goes to auction
Among other things at the auction you can buy the boy scout hat Armstrong and the flag of Purdue University, where he studied. In addition they will be sold to silver coins, which were released in memory of the space program "Apollo".

Manchester United adamant Anthony Martial won't be sold this summer
Chelsea are interested in signing Martial as a potential replacement for Eden Hazard , who is wanted by Real Madrid . Martial, now in the United States on United's pre-season tour, has a year remaining on his contract.

Tekashi 6ix9ine Robbed and Kidnapped After Filming a New Video
He was taken by ambulance to the hospital, where he now remains, as doctors perform various tests, including a CT scan. Sources told TMZ that three gunmen wearing hoods got out of the auto , grabbed 6ix9ine, and pistol-whipped him.

Francesco Molinari Stared Down Tiger Woods To Win The Open Championship
Woods, who shot 66 on Saturday, is paired with Molinari, two groups behind the final twosome of Spieth and Xander Schauffele. He sent it bouncing and rolling along the firm turf, down a hill and onto the green to about 10 feet away for an eagle.

Trump raises questions over seized Cohen recording
Trump has denied the affair. "Nothing in that conversation suggests that [Trump] had any knowledge of it in advance". Cohen had made a practice of recording conversations, unbeknownst to those he was speaking with.

Lincicome misses cut at PGA Tour event
The victor of two LPGA Tour majors among eight victories overall blamed those struggles on her putter and vowed to improve. Playing partner Conrad Shindler, who made the cut, described playing with Lincicome as "a pleasure, a treat".

U.S. faces resistance at G20 over trade deals
Mnuchin told reporters there had been no "macro" effect yet on the world's largest economy from the first round of tariffs . He said that there had been some "micro" effects such as retaliation against US-produced soybeans, lobsters and bourbon.

Ritz products recalled over Salmonella concerns
Two flavours of Uncle Ben's rice products are being recalled over fears of Salmonella contamination among the seasoning pouches. So far no complains of illnesses connected to the products included in the recall have been reported to Mondelez Global.

First Aquaman Movie Trailer Released
The actor was downright giddy speaking about the film, which is over five years in the making. "I'm really, really happy". Here is the upcoming movie's synopsis: We all have a superhero inside us, it just takes a bit of magic to bring it out.

Federal Bureau of Investigation documents show Trump campaign aide Carter Page was 'collaborating' with Russian Federation
Materials related to FISA operations and legal process are among the most highly classified and closely guarded in the government. The CNN host also asked Page if he had established relations with government officials, another claim found in the FISA warrant.