SC dismisses 10-year-old contempt cases against PCO judges

Arun Mishra had served 15 years as a high court judge before being elevated to the Supreme Court in July 2014.

Four senior judges of the Supreme Court on Friday mounted a virtual revolt against the chief justice, listing a litany of problems that they said are afflicting the country's highest court and warned they could destroy Indian democracy. "Our judiciary is reputed all over the world, independent and they will sort the matter themselves", said minister of state for law P P Chaudhury. His sentencing shows the need "for greater scrutiny and screening of judiciary", India's law minister Ravi Shankar Prasad said in June.

Congress President Rahul Gandhi on Friday said the claims made by four Supreme Court judges about maladministration within the apex court should be looked into.

The four judges - justices Ranjan Gogoi, Kurian Joseph and Madan B Lokur besides justice Chelameswar - released a letter they wrote to justice Misra a couple of months ago, conceding that he was the master of roster but that was "not a recognition of any superior authority, legal or factual of the chief justice over his colleagues".

"The Chief Justice of India, for the first time, has violated the most basic norm of any decision-making authority that no one shall be a judge in his or her own case", Bhushan wrote on Twitter on November 10, 2017.

The remarks assume significance as the Supreme Court today took up for consideration petitions requesting for an independent probe into the death of judge Loya who was hearing the Sohrabuddin Sheikh fake encounter case of 2004, in which various police officers and BJP president Amit Shah are named as parties.

More news: Micron Technology (NASDAQ:MU) Rating Reiterated by Deutsche Bank

The main allegation of the four senior judges is that the Chief Justice of India has not been transparent when it comes to discharging his duties. "There is no pleasure in this, we were compelled to do this, the administration of the Supreme Court is not in order", said the senior Judge. In 1977, Justice HR Khanna was the lone dissenting judge on a Supreme Court bench that ruled in favour of the government in a key case during the Emergency (1975-77). "When I came to know of the extraordinary step taken by him & other judges, I thought must meet him".

Justice Gogoi said "nobody is breaking the rank and it is a discharge of debt to the nation which we have done".

The chief justice did not immediately respond to telephone calls from Reuters seeking comment.

Senior advocate Dushyant Dave, representing the Bombay Lawyers Association, told the bench that the Bombay High Court was seized of the matter and the bench should not hear the plea.

The main issue appeared to be the assignment of cases by the CJI in the Supreme Court. "We owe a responsibility to the institution and the nation".

The CJI, for his part, is said to have indicated that he respected every judge and distribution of cases to each of them was done in a "fair manner", keeping the overall load on the judiciary.

Related News:

  • Trump's Vulgar Remarks on Immigration Confirmed by Senator

    Durbin is part of a bipartisan group of six senators who announced Thursday the framework of a compromise on immigration. Dick Durbin of IL , the only Democrat in the room, said Trump had indeed said what he was reported to have said.
    Niantic Announces Pokemon Go Community Day Event Featuring Surfing Pikachu

    Niantic Announces Pokemon Go Community Day Event Featuring Surfing Pikachu

    What better way to kick off the Pokemon Go Community Day than to feature the beloved mascot Pikachu . For January's event, Niantic has already confirmed the special Pokemon will be Surfing Pikachu.

    Paul Ryan says Trump's slur against African countries is 'unfortunate, unhelpful'

    Durbin said "shitholes" was "the exact word used by the president not just once but repeatedly ". When told that Trump denied making the remarks, Durbin said: "It speaks for itself".
  • Apple (AAPL) Earns Buy Rating from Piper Jaffray Companies

    It is positive, as 52 investors sold AAPL shares while 1034 reduced holdings. 116 funds opened positions while 640 raised stakes. Her Majesty The Queen In Right Of The Province Of Alberta As Represented By Alberta Invest Management Corp owns 257,600 shares.
    Supermassive Black Hole is Caught Letting Out Massive 'Burps'

    Supermassive Black Hole is Caught Letting Out Massive 'Burps'

    The team found radiation at the centre of the galaxy that showed that the black hole was feasting about million years ago. These "burps" were followed by a period of rest, which researchers describe as the black hole 'taking a nap'.

    Revenue Estimates Analysis Bank of America Corporation (BAC)

    Mariner Wealth Advsrs Limited Liability Company reported 121,504 shares. 34,038 are held by Folger Nolan Fleming Douglas Cap Mgmt. It shows a stock price recent trends and movement that can help investor and traders in trading. (NYSE:RSG) for 1.21M shares.
  • El Salvador slams 'deplorable' comment attributed to Trump

    El Salvador slams 'deplorable' comment attributed to Trump

    The group of senators had come to the White House to discuss a potential compromise on immigration. According to Time , the president's remarks drew widespread condemnation from world leaders.
    Gov. Abbott directs TEA to take action to fix special education

    Gov. Abbott directs TEA to take action to fix special education

    School district officials said they expected they would receive less monitoring if they served 8.5 percent of students or fewer. TEA has denied allegations that it capped services for students.
    Speaker Paul Ryan calls Pres. Trump's immigrant remarks 'unfortunate' and 'unhelpful'

    Speaker Paul Ryan calls Pres. Trump's immigrant remarks 'unfortunate' and 'unhelpful'

    Trump comments: "First thing that came to my mind was very unfortunate, unhelpful". "I think it's important we celebrate that". The Irish people were really looked down upon in those days.
  • At Least 15 Dead After Southern California Mudslides

    At Least 15 Dead After Southern California Mudslides

    The destruction was described by Santa Barbara County Sheriff Bill Brown as looking " like a World War I battlefield ". After a wildfire , burned vegetation and charred soil create a water repellent layer which blocks water absorption.
    NYC Sues Fossil Fuel Industry over Hidden Costs of Climate Change

    NYC Sues Fossil Fuel Industry over Hidden Costs of Climate Change

    The company's filing also argued the lawsuits were politically motivated and linked to cases brought by the states of NY and MA . The mayor's office noted in a recent statement that Hurricane Sandy was a lesson for us on climate change's destructivity.
    Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp: 'Virgil van Dijk may not face Manchester City'

    Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp: 'Virgil van Dijk may not face Manchester City'

    Last weekend, Van Dijk marked his first appearance since a £75m move from Southampton with the winning goal as Liverpool defeated Everton in the FA Cup third round.


Most liked

Trump's immigration remarks denounced by Florida lawmakers, represent second snub towards Haitians
The New York Times , NBC News , BuzzFeed and CNN confirmed reports of the comment . Dick Durbin (D-Ill.), told MSNBC that Graham confronted Trump on his remarks.

California man confesses to 1993 killing in TV interview, seeks forgiveness
Hawkins, Shanna Culver and Curtis Culver were booked on charges of murder and are being held at the Shasta County Jail. KRCR-TV reported that police said one of the Culvers has also confessed, but declined to specify which one.

Dark Souls Remastered announced for PC with improvements
In terms of resolution, Dark Souls: Remastered will offer native 4K resolution at 60 fps. The box set is slated to release the same day as Dark Souls: Remastered on May 24, 2018.

Donald Trump vows to shakeup libel laws after damaging book published
Trump was 70 when he took office on January 20, 2017, making him the oldest person ever elected to the nation's highest office. And as the 45th President celebrates his first year in office, we take at his funniest pics from the past 365 days.

Oil Prices Spike Amid Extremely Large API Crude Oil Draw (USO)
Analysts said that could have been the result of extreme cold temperatures across the United States. The price for Brent crude oil , the global benchmark, was up 0.44 percent at 9:20 a.m.

Southwestern Energy (NYSE:SWN) Holdings Trimmed by California State Teachers Retirement System
Cowen set a $9.00 target price on Southwestern Energy and gave the stock a "buy" rating in a report on Wednesday, October 18th. Several analysts are forecasting growth estimate of Southwestern Energy Company for the current quarter to be 50%.

'Sneaky' Feinstein Needs to Be Primaried
We strongly believed that publishing the disputed document whose existence we and others were reporting was in the public interest .

Putin declares North Korea victor in standoff with South Korea, US
Critics say Kim may be trying to divide Seoul and Washington in a bid to weaken worldwide pressure and sanctions on the North. No conversation has been publicly reported between any sitting USA president and a North Korean leader in decades, if ever.

Pakistan routs NZ's lower order
The 36-year-old added Pakistan can replicate their Champions Trophy turn of fate and upstage New Zealand in the series. The second match had nothing different expect Pakistan batting first, and they were again short of runs.

MLB Trade Rumors: Manny Machado Being Pursued By Arizona Diamondbacks
Right-hander Kevin Gausman and second baseman Jonathan Schoop are Baltimore's only arbitration-eligible players without deals. Reports earlier Friday had the O's heading to an arbitration hearing with Machado after failing to agree by the 1 p.m.

RB Leipzig dismiss early Keita switch
RB Leipzig coach Ralph Hasenhuttl ruled out any suggestion they would consider letting Keita depart for Liverpool this month. But Klopp has admitted he will only replace Coutinho if the right player becomes available.

Loyal Dog Walks 40 Miles to Find Previous Owners
Cathleen is not the only dog who was recently reunited - however briefly - with her owners in a remarkable fashion. Cathleen the dog missed her old family so much she trekked 20 miles to find them on two different occasions.

Brokerages Expect Tenet Healthcare Corp (THC) to Announce $1.29 EPS
Vetr upgraded QUALCOMM Incorporated (NASDAQ:QCOM) rating on Wednesday, August 19. (NYSE:AI) rating on Wednesday, October 28. ValuEngine downgraded shares of Tenet Healthcare from a hold rating to a sell rating in a report on Sunday, December 31st.

Chris Matthews joked about putting a 'Bill Cosby pill' in Hillary's water
Before Clinton shows up Matthews cracks a few snide jokes to his crew. "Runway walk", he could be heard saying . He has a long history of making disparaging comments about Clinton. " Hardball " was hosted on CNBC at the time.

Martin O'Neill in talks with Stoke City
Republic of Ireland manager Martin O'Neill had no comment for waiting media as he entered a banquet in Dublin on Friday night. Should Keane not leave then Steve Walford, Steve Guppy and Seamus McDonagh are in contention for roles.